Coach tygr:
I love the 4 out with permanent SC against any zone. Have the SC move back and forth between the spots on any action. I promise you they will get lost as the ball rotates and players flash to the logo. Make sure the SC moves BEHIND the basket. When the ball gets passed or dribbled into the logo, they should flash to an open spot in front of the basket. When the ball is on the wing, they should be ready for a pass for a quick flank ‘em move.
You can experiment with a 1 or 2 guard formation. Traditional zone attacks say you should go even against odd, and odd against even. I think you should throw that out the window, especially if you have a good PG that penetrates well. A drive and kick when help comes would be one of many good options to get the possession started against a 1-3-1, forcing the defense to hep and recover with the ball and players moving. The additional advantage of the 1 guard formation is that it will result in more corner coverage automatically. When the ball goes to the corner, you should have the SC ball side, someone cutting to the logo, and someone filling the wing. You will have the defense outnumbered and someone will be open.
The biggest challenge against a 1-3-1 is not your half court action IMO. The problem is teams like to surprise you and extend their defense and trap at half or 3/4 court when they are in the 1-3-1. Here is what happens. While your PG is bringing the ball up, the other four players run to their spots in the 4-out formation. When the top “chaser” in the 1-3-1 forces the PG to one side or the other, the trap is sprung. Because the other four offensive players are on their spots, this creates some horrible, long passing lanes where passes are easily picked off and returned for touchdowns. They are hanging your PG out to dry.
The solution? RUN YOUR OFFENSE, but make sure your players come back and position themselves appropriately EVEN THOUGH THEY ARE NOT IN THE FRONT COURT. Please see the video “Press Break” on this topic. Pay special attention to the third chapter, “Player Positioning”, starting at the 16-minute mark. Watch Rick as he walks backward down the court.
I promise you, if several teams in your league run the 1-3-1, someone, if not all, will try and trap out of it. You need to be prepared.